Two People, Same Weight One Healthy, One at Risk (Here's Why)

Meet Riya and Neha. Both are 5’4”. Both weigh 62 kilos. Both think they’re “average.” Riya eats clean, walks 8,000 steps daily, and does light yoga. Neha eats on time too — it’s just that her meals include samosas, sugary chai, and “Netflix dinner specials.” On paper, they’re the same. On the inside? They couldn’t be more different. Because health isn’t about weight. It’s about composition.
The Big Lie of BMI
For decades, we’ve been taught to worship the BMI (Body Mass Index) — that neat little formula dividing weight by height squared. It gives you a number, a category, and the illusion of understanding your health. “Underweight.” “Normal.” “Overweight.” “Obese.” Simple, right? Yes — but also dangerously outdated. Here’s why: BMI doesn’t care what your weight is made of — muscle, fat, water, or even bone density. You could be a fit athlete or a sedentary desk worker with the same BMI. The BMI scale would treat you both the same. It’s like grading two students who both scored 80 — one through brilliance, the other through copying. The number matches, but the story doesn’t.
Body Fat Percentage: The Real Game-Changer
Body fat percentage (BFP) tells a far truer story. It measures how much of your body weight is actually fat tissue. And that matters — because fat behaves like an organ. It releases hormones, stores toxins, and affects everything from insulin sensitivity to inflammation levels. When your fat percentage goes too high, your risk of heart disease, diabetes, and metabolic syndrome skyrockets — even if your BMI looks “normal.” A person can look slim, yet carry high internal fat around vital organs — especially the liver, heart, and pancreas. That’s called “metabolically obese normal weight” (MONW) — or as fitness trainers now call it, “skinny fat.”
Humor Break: The Great Indian Family Illusion
Aunties at weddings have one universal line of defense: “Beta, you look so healthy!” Translation: You look slightly rounder than last time. In India, “healthy” is often confused with “hefty.” And “thin” is automatically assumed to mean “weak.” But the truth? Half our “healthy-looking” population has fatty liver, insulin resistance, or prediabetes. We’re not overweight — we’re overfat.
The Science Behind It: Why Fat Percentage Matters More Than Weight
1. Visceral Fat Is the Villain
This is the fat stored deep inside the abdomen — wrapping around your organs. It’s invisible but toxic. It releases inflammatory chemicals like IL-6 and TNF-alpha, which damage blood vessels and trigger insulin resistance.
2. Muscle Protects the Heart
Muscle mass boosts metabolism, stabilizes blood sugar, and reduces strain on the heart. So, someone heavier but muscular is often healthier than someone lighter but soft.
3. Fat Distribution Matters
Apple-shaped people (more fat around waist) face higher cardiac risk than pear-shaped ones (fat around hips and thighs). In India, even small belly fat counts big — a waist circumference above 90 cm (men) or 80 cm (women) is a warning sign.
Data That Hits Home
According to The Lancet Global Health (2022), nearly 37% of Indians with normal BMI still have dangerous levels of visceral fat. A 2023 AIIMS study found that urban Indian adults under 40 are showing metabolic profiles similar to Westerners in their 50s. Translation: our bodies are aging faster than our mirrors are showing. Why? Stress. Processed carbs. Sedentary jobs. And a national love story with sugar.
Deep Thinking: The Weight of Illusion
We love measuring things we can see — kilograms, calories, kilometers. But the real danger lives in what we can’t see. Two people, same weight — one carrying muscle, the other inflammation. Two diets, same calories — one nourishing, one numbing. Modern health isn’t about losing weight. It’s about losing risk. Because you don’t want a lighter body. You want a longer life.
How to Measure the Right Way
No, you don’t need a NASA lab to find your body fat percentage. Here are realistic ways:
1. Smart Scale:
Affordable and fairly accurate for trends (though not perfect).
2. DEXA Scan:
The gold standard for precise fat and muscle breakdown — ideal for high-risk or clinical cases.
3. Waist-to-Height Ratio:
Simplest method — your waist should be less than half your height. If not, you’re storing more fat than you think.
4. The Mirror Test:
Not about vanity — about awareness. If you’re gaining around the middle but weight stays the same, it’s fat gain, not “just bloating.”
Humor Break: Scales and Lies
We’ve all done it. Step on the scale, exhale dramatically, and feel 200 grams lighter. Or shift our feet and declare: “See, it’s just water weight.” But the scale is only showing gravity’s opinion — not your biology’s truth. If you want real progress, track your fat percentage, waist, sleep quality, and energy. Because good health isn’t about lighter mirrors — it’s about longer mornings.
The Fix: From Fat to Fit (Without Losing Your Mind)
  1. Strength > Sweat: Cardio burns calories; strength training builds protection. Aim for at least 2 days a week of muscle work.
  2. Protein Power: Indians under-eat protein. Add eggs, lentils, paneer, or fish — and cut down empty carbs.
  3. Fiber is Your Friend: Vegetables and fruits aren’t just vitamins — they’re gut regulators that help manage fat storage.
  4. Sleep Well, Stress Less: Sleep deprivation increases visceral fat by up to 30% (Harvard Study, 2020). Chronic stress triggers cortisol — your body’s “store more fat” hormone.
  5. Ditch the Scale Obsession: Track inches, not kilos. Track energy, not perfection.
The Final Beat
If two people weigh the same but live completely different lives, one could be aging faster from the inside without knowing it. So stop asking, “How much do you weigh?” Start asking, “How much of that is worth keeping?” Because the real goal isn’t to fit into jeans. It’s to fit into life — stronger, lighter, longer. If this blog made you rethink your weighing scale obsession, share it. It might just help someone shift from “losing weight” to “gaining health.”
Related Posts
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *

Open chat
Hello 👋
Can we help you?